Categories

Powered by TypePad

« The Oxford Picture Dictionary: English/Japanese | Main | Have Your Japanese Corrected by Native Speakers' Journal »

January 09, 2007

Comments

Harvey

That's hardcore, I feel humbled.

Having "real" skills to back up language is a must these days to land a job outside of English teaching I would say. It's so tough to juggle both! Yongfook is 大したもんだ!

Sorry

Sorry, boring and a waste of time interview. "Major achievement?" None. "Faux pax?" Can't think of one, sorry. "So, you somehow magically became a Japanese expert from scratch. Any tips?" Not really.

Yeah, great.

Unfortunate name, as well.

Will Jasprizza

Dear Sorry

I wonder perhaps if you actually read the article? If you did you would notice Jon talking about steps such as beginning with a basic grammar, hammering away at vocab and repetitive practice for the JLPT 2kyu. No magic here, just hard slog. And I make no claims as to Jon being an expert, he deprecates on that point and the title of the post is LEARNER Stories....

Criticism is only useful if it is constructive. If you have any constructive points to make I am more than happy to consider them. If you think that you have a more interesting story then by all means get it touch and I will interview you.

You might want to consider too including your email when you post. Anonymity is evidence of lack of conviction. People tend to listen more when the speaker has the balls to stand behind his words.

regards

Will

Still sorry

1. "I wonder perhaps if you actually read the article?" I wonder perhaps if you're a bit biased as you're the person who wrote the article. Your opening line, found in almost every "letters to the editor" column in a small-town newspaper (usually regarding some terrible movie or populist CD), is broad foreshadowing that cliched writing is to follow.

Yes, just as I bothered to post about it, I took the time to read it.

2. Constructive? I stated that, as a reader, I found few responses/ideas of value. As a writer, I know that this is harsh. However, it's honest (which is why I wrote 'sorry"). If it's "Learner stories", I want to know how to learn better. I'm a student of Japanese. I study every day. If there's clear, useful advice here, it's well-hidden.

3. Uh, no. I can't think of anyone that would utilitize my email for any practical purpose other than to bother me via spam or useless "opinions". I don't have the time.

Further, your use of the word "balls" (a challenge that equates posting my email address with masculinity) is an obvious bait that is best ignored. If we met in person, yes, I might not bother challenging your opinons, just as I ignore people every day; sometimes, it's just not worth the bother.

Interview interesting people with ideas. This is my constructive criticism.

yongfook

Angry Person > if you are a "studier of Japanese" and you study every day there's probably not a lot anyone can teach you. You're already way more dedicated than I am.

I think the problem here is one of perception. You've come into "Learner Stories" expecting to be given something. I think however, the category / title "Learner Stories" is sufficiently broad to cover both "here's how I learned Japanese" stories and "here's what I do with my learned Japanese". Think of this interview as the latter.

Sorry that none of it was relevant to you. Good luck with the J-go.

I'm not angry at all - why would I be?

I accept your apology for being dull and appreciate your good wishes.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Search this site



Ads by Google

Stats


Analytics